You're literally making a mountain out of a molehill, just like Andy does.
Has any of Andy's critics, besides Turimel, ever denied that he's male? NO. This one is extremely clear and simple: everyone agrees that he's male.
Was Andy born with a male body? NO. This one is equally clear and simple: he was born with a female body, AND presented and lived as female for give-or-take 20 years.
The ONLY reason any discussion around Andy's gender turn dicey is because he adamantly denied this second fact for years IN ORDER TO shift responsibility for his past abuse onto other people, including his RL sister.
The solution to this is simple: we only need to stick to the FACTS. Andy Blake is a man who was born with a female body, presented as a girl for about 20 years, and started abusing people back when he was female-presenting, which is why his AFAB status needs to remain public. There! Clear, simple, and NOT stepping on the toes of non-abusive trans people who want to keep their birth status secret. No need to get into any kind of wank ever again.
Re: DIscussion of Facebook messages: Carlanime/Necromommycon and Andy
Has any of Andy's critics, besides Turimel, ever denied that he's male? NO. This one is extremely clear and simple: everyone agrees that he's male.
Was Andy born with a male body? NO. This one is equally clear and simple: he was born with a female body, AND presented and lived as female for give-or-take 20 years.
The ONLY reason any discussion around Andy's gender turn dicey is because he adamantly denied this second fact for years IN ORDER TO shift responsibility for his past abuse onto other people, including his RL sister.
The solution to this is simple: we only need to stick to the FACTS. Andy Blake is a man who was born with a female body, presented as a girl for about 20 years, and started abusing people back when he was female-presenting, which is why his AFAB status needs to remain public. There! Clear, simple, and NOT stepping on the toes of non-abusive trans people who want to keep their birth status secret. No need to get into any kind of wank ever again.