Fact: Brittany wrote a letter accusing her father of abuse.
Fact: This fits with Andy's established pattern of alienating children from their parents by creating or exaggerating memories of abuse, and having them write letters to their parents about it.
Speculation: Brittany's accusations of abuse may be partially or entirely fabricated.
Fact: There is no way to know for sure.
As long as the last fact is kept in mind, I don't think you should ban all discussions that deal with elements of speculation. The result may be that actual facts (like the first three) get lost in the process, and in some ways I think that does Brittany a disservice, because in many ways she's Andy's most unfortunate victim. She will never have the chance to reconnect with her parents.
Re: A note from the mod
I agree, but it's a fine line. For example:
Fact: Brittany wrote a letter accusing her father of abuse.
Fact: This fits with Andy's established pattern of alienating children from their parents by creating or exaggerating memories of abuse, and having them write letters to their parents about it.
Speculation: Brittany's accusations of abuse may be partially or entirely fabricated.
Fact: There is no way to know for sure.
As long as the last fact is kept in mind, I don't think you should ban all discussions that deal with elements of speculation. The result may be that actual facts (like the first three) get lost in the process, and in some ways I think that does Brittany a disservice, because in many ways she's Andy's most unfortunate victim. She will never have the chance to reconnect with her parents.